Creative Teaching Ideas for

JOHNNY TREMAIN

by Esther Forbes (1943)

Fun, hands-on ways to teach this great book!

Plus: Takeaway Topics, Learning Links, and Prop Ideas

Johnny Tremain, winner of the 1944 Newbery Medal, is one of the finest historical novels ever written for children [about] the defining events leading up to the American Revolutionary War. Fourteen-year-old Johnny Tremain, an apprentice silversmith with a bright future ahead of him, injures his hand in a tragic accident, forcing him to look for other work. In his new job as a horse-boy, riding for the patriotic newspaper, The Boston Observer, and as a messenger for the Sons of Liberty, he becomes involved in the pivotal events shaping the American Revolution, from the Boston Tea Party to the first shots fired at Lexington.  —Amazon.com 


LitWits makes a small commission on anything you buy through our Amazon affiliate links.

Explore this book with your kids, LitWits style!

Meet the author

Start your experience of this story by introducing the kids to the author, so kids can see the connections between her lived story and her written story.

Below is our kid-friendly biography of Esther Forbes—it's a great discussion starter, and we've got a worksheet for author note-taking, too.

Set includes all worksheets and activity printables

Make a healing poultice

A LitWits activity from the Rising Action

Johnny’s injury is what brings him down–but in the end, it helps him “stand up.”  His wound heals faster than his heart, but he learns! The first step in his healing process, though, is Gran’ Hopper’s stinky linseed poultice. To help kids see, feel and smell why a poultice might be comforting, we dampened an actual linseed poultice we’d made, and let them experience its soothing relief.


As a take-home, we had them choose herbs, write down a recipe for healing, grind the herbs in a pestle, and put their concoction in a small muslin bag. This let our kids get “hands-on” with some historical and thematic elements of this story, and learn a little about colonial medicine, too.


SUPPLIES
  • assorted herbs (our preprinted labels feature herbs we found at the grocery store)
  • at least one mortar and pestle to share
  • small muslin bags
  • herb labels for the “buffet” (in our printables)
  • recipe handout (in our printables)


FOR DISCUSSION

We all tend to take modern medicine for granted. In colonial times, doctors had few effective medicines available, and many still relied on techniques like bloodletting, herbal medicines, and English folk remedies like burnt toads! Ask the kids which technique might have actually worked, and why.

Doctors often struggled to treat disease—especially in the cities. Ask the kids why illness might have spread more easily in Boston as opposed to the countryside.

While the kids are choosing their herbs and making their recipes, you might show them this video about colonial apothecaries.

BookBites

Share friendship fare

A LitWits activity from the Rising Action

BookBites is the part of our literary experience when we get to “taste the story.”  We choose a food right out of the book, and it has to meet at least one criterion:  it’s important to a plot point, it has thematic significance, or it’s unfamiliar for reasons of culture, era, or location.

Bread and cheese represent the friendship with Rab that helps Johnny transform for the better. These staples are what Rab offers him at their first meeting, and when Johnny decides to approach Lyte with the cup as proof they’re related, Rab outfits him with clothes, bread, and cheese. So this combo is representative of their combo.

The special punch Johnny made for the Sons of Liberty meeting is a less familiar treat, and it represents Johnny’s involvement in America’s changes.  Change is a major theme of this book--so these BookBites meet all our criteria.

While the kids bond over these symbols of collaboration, you might share a brief overview of the battle at Lexington.


For a later workshop where we mailed LitWits Kits of supplies ahead of time, we made a label for wrapping individual packets of tea, a "Patriot Punch" mix, and a Boston Observer for wrapping up the bread and cheese. The kids loved finding the actual pig ad from the story in the paper. :)

Mark Johnny's journey on an Old Boston map

A LitWits project from the Rising Action


In Johnny’s darkest hour he travels through Boston on foot, winding up on his mother’s grave. To follow in his footsteps, we keyed an old map of that city with textural story elements, each one representing an important place. This helped  kids “get into” the historical setting in physical ways, and it gave us a chance to talk about Johnny’s inner journey, too.


SUPPLIES

  • bits of tin foil

  • short pieces of twine

  • salt crystals

  • gold glitter

  • pebbles

  • bits of newspaper

  • loose tea

  • gold sequins

  • googly eyes

  • watercolors

  • copies of the numbered map template (in our printables), printed on cardstock

  • teacher key (in our printables)


We glued the map to a pocket folder and used it to store worksheets. If you’d like to do that, add pocket folders to the supplies list.

DIRECTIONS

Setup

Have the kids look at this 1775 map of Boston and see if they can identify what the symbols might represent, such as the docks, the bridge, the hills, and the wall.  Explain that back in Johnny Tremain’s time, the shape of Boston was a lot different than it is today. Around the time of the Revolutionary War, the city was almost an island, with one small strip of land, the “Neck,” connecting it to the mainland.

Since that time, such a large amount of land has been “filled,” or reclaimed from the sea and the Charles River, that the city has almost doubled in size. Show a modern map that illustrates the reclaimed land vs. original land. You might want to talk about the impact this would have had on the environment and animal habitats along the shore.

Now distribute the map and “walk” through old Boston (and Johnny’s story) with the kids, handing out the textural items as you go. 


Getting our bearings

1.  Where does the story open?  Place silver (tin foil) on Hancock’s Wharf at Lapham’s silversmith shop. This also stands for Johnny’s pride in being a superior silversmith apprentice, and the hot spilled silver that ruined his hand and career. This is a good time to discuss the art and process of silversmithing in Colonial times, and share any props or videos.


2.  Where does Johnny go when Isannah hurts his feelings by saying “I hate your hand!”?  Follow Johnny’s walk through Boston all the way to the town gates, and glue a loop of twine on the gallows (on the Neck!).


3.  Find the “foot of the Common” and put salt on the salt marshes. Why would there be salt there?  It’s an estuarine habitat, where the Charles River mixes with the salty water of the tides.

4.  Make your way to Beacon Hill and put the glitter of candles there. Talk about why lights in the windows would suggest a family was wealthy. Note that tallow candles were common, but they were smelly, drippy, and didn’t last long. Those with extra money might use sweet smelling beeswax or bayberry candles. Families with access to the whaling industry would have used spermaceti, or whale-oil candles. Ask the kids which candles the Lytes and Hancocks would have used. 


5.  Follow Johnny’s footsteps to the Copp’s Hill. Talk about the meaning of the “dead worthies of Boston,” with their slate grave markers, as opposed to Mother, whose grave is unmarked. Talk about what kinds of things make a person “worthy.” Honor Johnny’s mother with a tombstone of her own (a pebble).

The events that followed


6.  Where does Johnny eventually find work?  Place a bit of newspaper at The Boston Observer office on Salt Lane. Talk about the role of The Observer, and other Whig newspapers, in preparing Bostonians for the revolution. What kinds of activities happened there besides newspaper printing? The Sons of Liberty met there in secret! 


7.  What important event took place in the Boston Harbor? (Discuss the “tea party” events of Chapter ) Glue some loose tea in the harbor near Griffin’s Wharf.


8.  Read aloud Paul Revere’s “one if by land, two if by sea” plan as overheard by Johnny as he awakens in Dr. Warren’s surgery, in Chapter 10. Glue two lanterns (gold sequins) on North Church. Show students a map of Paul Revere’s and Billy Dawes’ rides that night.

9.  What was happening across the Charles River as the lanterns were being hung in the church spire? (Read Paul Revere’s words again for a hint) Glue two watching (googly) eyes in Charles Town.


Finish the maps by painting all the water around Boston and Charles Town with beautiful watercolors while listening to American Colonial music.

If you have time, use Google maps to show students current day Boston. Find as many locations from the map project as possible using the satellite view.

Make a maker's mark

A LitWits project from the Rising Action


Silversmiths’ marks are important in this story  — and silver makes its own kind of mark on Johnny — so we had our kids make their own.  They loved the idea of marking their own goods! And this helped get them thinking about what emblem might stand for them, and that naturally makes them think about what they stand for.


DIRECTIONS

Distribute the design worksheet (if purchased) and/or give a brief overview about the origins and purpose of maker’s marks. Ask the kids how they were used in the story. Then have the kids  apply their own designs to silver labels or tags with black markers.

FOR DISCUSSION

 While the kids are creating their own “maker’s mark,” show them a colonial silversmith at work, and remind them that silversmiths were an important part of colonial society. Four main families dominated the Boston silversmith industry: the Edwards, the Burts, the Hurds, and the Reveres.  Silversmiths provided  items that were not only beautiful but necessary, too--candlesticks, for instance, weren't just for romance or emergencies back then.  Show images of commonly used silver items.

Ask the kids to come up with some other reasons why silversmiths might have been “revered.” (We couldn’t pass that up.) Have them contrast the makers and their products with, for instance, a modern company that makes plastic tubs for storing food, or a company that makes flashlights and lanterns. What are the differences, from the obvious to the nuanced?

Practice persuasiv writing

A LitWits activity from the Rising Action

Johnny’s unsuccessful attempt to persuade Merchant Lyte of their family connection makes us cringe--he clearly didn't "know his audience," nor did he have credibility with Mr. Lyte. But there's more to the art of persuasion than doing your research or having credentials.  It matters how  someone communicates. What if a speaker didn't make eye contact, or added lots of “ums” and “uhs”?  On the other hand, it's also possible to be too smooth, too loud, too assertive. It was Rab's quiet ways that persuaded Johnny to better himself. 

When it comes to writing  persuasively, rhetorical appeals can be very effective, as Sam Adams knew. Our "Power Writing" worksheet asks kids to do away with those appeals, in ways that would have appalled Mr. Adams--and that makes it easy to see what a difference they make.  

Hold a Whigs vs. Tories debate

A LitWits activity from the Rising Action

The Whigs and Tories sure made things interesting, didn’t they!  We brought those feisty folks right into the room with a debate. We chose to argue about the issue of British control over the American colonies. This helped kids see both points of view on four different issues, so they learned about political history and gained a life skill, too!

SETUP
 
As we read in the book, some colonists, called Loyalists or Tories, believed that America should remain a British colony. They felt that the British Crown was a legitimate source of authority, and that rebelling would be morally wrong. They may have also had a personal stake in keeping the Colonies under the Crown, such as business reasons. During the debate activity, share some of the specific arguments that Whigs and Tories made regarding loyalty to Britain.

DIRECTIONS

Make two copies of the questions and cut the questions apart .  Divide the kids into two teams. Give each team the same question, one at a time. (Or you could give each team the whole sheet – whatever suits your goals and schedule.)

We’ve included a kid-friendly corollary for each hot topic. The issue of taxation without representation, for instance, is a lot more interesting when we’re talking about your allowance.

Use a ruse

A LitWits activity from the Climax

Billy Dawes has to get past enemy lines to warn other colonists that the British troops are coming.  To do this, he comes up with a ruse. So we had volunteers pull a ruse and a secret mission, and do their best to get past a volunteer Redcoat. They had to be very persuasive! This helped them get “in the shoes of” brave patriots like Billy.

SUPPLIES: 
 You’ll just need some dress-up clothes--a red coat comes in handy, and a hat or two-- along with the ruses & secret missions. (You can make up your own, or use those in our printables.).
This “farmer” has run into a suspicious Redcoat.
Unable to answer his probing questions . . .
. . . she is revealed as a Whig spy! Paul Revere ponders the situation with grave concern.

Printables Previews

The worksheets and printables used for our activities are sold as a complete set.

Not pictured: author note-taking worksheet


Common Core State Standards Alignment for the comprehensive use of our teaching ideas and materials is also included for grades 3, 4, 5 and 6. 

Takeaway Topics

Why we chose this book for a "field trip"

This book is less about a revolution than about a boy's recovery, inside and out. Though the war gives him a chance to "stand up" and prove he's become a man, the story itself is about recovering from loss and reshaping one's life to be something shiny and new.  We loved the perfect metaphor of silversmithing in this book, and the many opportunities the historian author gives us to learn what life was like in this tumultuous period. So we chose it for one of our experiential workshops. It turned out to be one of our best--not just fun, but packed with great takeaway topics, which we're sharing below.


In our workshops, we did our best to make these teaching points tangible, meaningful, and memorable in the kids' hands. It's amazing how much kids can learn while they're "just" having fun! 

Happy teaching!
Becky and Jenny

Takeaway 1

Persuasion

Persuasion is called for many times during this story, whether people are trying to win political converts, increase attendance at meetings, or sneak past enemy lines. Persuasion is a form of teaching, and there’s both an art and a science to it. The debate activity helps kids understand the strengths and weaknesses of arguments, the ruse activity can help them see the importance of tone and body language, and the creative writing worksheets give them a chance to practice rhetorical devices such as pathos and ethos.

Hands-on connections in this guide“Whigs & Tories Debate” activity, “Use a Ruse” activity, creative writing worksheets

Takeaway 2

Colonial Boston

There are many rich subtopics within the setting of colonial Boston. The map project gives you a chance to explore old Boston on paper and compare it to the modern topography. Once the kids have got their bearings, you might want to talk about colonial medicine (and do the poultice project), colonial politics (and have a Whigs vs. Tories debate), or Use a Ruse to sneak past the British), and/or colonial silversmithing (and do the maker's mark project).


Hands-on connections in this guide: “Healing Poultice” project, “Old Boston Map” project, “Use a Ruse” activity, “Whigs & Tories Debate” activity, "Power Writing" worksheet, “Make Your Mark” project

Takeaway 3

Transformation

This book is all about crucial changes and healing. The crucible itself, as a prop, is an important symbol of Johnny's "trial by fire;" his terrible wound isn't just physical, but mental and emotional too. He has hard lessons to  earn from his accident and other painful experiences--and each one reshapes him, like silver, into something more beautiful and useful than he was before. America, too, is in the throes of transformation. The story ends with both hope and pain, and without a clear resolution. Why the author might have done this is something worth talking about.

Hands-on connections in this guide:  “Healing Poultice” activity, “Use a Ruse” activity, symbols and themes worksheet, metalsmithing props
Johnny Tremain  is chock-full of other subjects to explore, too--from the origins of political parties to colonialism, equality, the Revolutionary War, and much more.   Scroll down to see our curated Learning Links for more tangential teaching opportunities, and to see how we brought this book and its ideas to life. 

Learning Links

Explore these links to supplement your reading experience, research points of interest, and prompt tangential learning opportunities.


About the Book & Author

Goodreads reviews
Brief biographical summary - Bookology Magazine
Midlength biography - Encyclopedia.com
Biographical notes - Clark University)
Biography - Gale Literature Resource Center
Biography included in Forbes Papers Collection description - American Antiquarian Society


Story Supplements

Producing silver by hand
Colonial medicine
8 maps that show Boston's changing shorelines - WBUR News
Old newspaper article – How to make and apply a linseed poultice
Colonial silversmithing techniques
Silversmith demonstration recreating a 1704 piece
Slavery in Massachusetts
Whigs & Tories (UK Parliament)
Boston Tea Party events (BTP Historical Society)
The Rhetorical Triangle - Indiana University
Colonial silversmithing (video) - Colonial Williamsburg
Boston Tea Party – info and video (History.com)
Colonial apothecaries (video) - Townsends
Boston Tea Party – detail and images (National Humanities Center)
Copp’s Hill Graveyard - Boston.gov
Old North Church, Boston - official site
The real story of Paul Revere’s ride
Revere’s account of his ride
Freedom trail sites
Origins of “Yankee Doodle” (NPR)


Beyond the Book

Life of Paul Revere
Paul Revere’s other (more important) ride
Paul Revere House
About Revere silver (Metropolitan Museum of Art)
Colonial life in Massachusetts
How to identify silver hallmarks
Historian’s rich blog about Boston and the American Revolution, with focus on sensory elements

Prop Ideas

When choosing props for our live workshops, we always try to focus on two important categories: props that are unique to the setting, because they help kids understand “what that was like,” and props that are symbolic of themes, because they make big ideas visual and tangible. Both kinds of props generate those wide-eyed, “aha!” moments.

Below is an overview of the display we put together for our live workshop, and under that we've given more details. You could easily have your kids contribute items to a table over time, as the book is being read.


Sometimes we create a printable prop; click the button to see the list for this book.

Set includes all worksheets and activity printables

Old silver & loose tea

He went on to Mr. Revere’s. The silversmith was busy drawing a political cartoon concerning teaand tyranny. He did not draw well — not the way he made silver. As he drew, his children crowded about him, standing on the rungs of his chair, breathing down his neck, dropping crumbs of gingerbread into his hair; but Paul Revere took all this confusion as he took everything else, without any fussing.

Iron ladle & tin plates

"Johnny," cried Mrs. Lapham, ‘"sn’t it time to pour? Look, the silver is melted and begun to wink." It was true.
[ . . . }
When he came to, he was stretched out upon the floor. Dorcas was trying to pour brandy down his throat. Mrs. Lapham had plunged the burned hand into a panful of flour and was yelling at Madge to hurry with her bread poultice.

Poultice herbs

His hand had been done up in a linseed poultice. The smell of the linseed was stifling, and now, on the second day, the pain had really begun. His arm throbbed to the shoulder. Gran’ Hopper was in the kitchen, talking to Mrs. Lapham.

"Mind you keep that poultice wet. Just leave it wrapped up and wet it now and then with lime water. There’s more luck than anything else in things like this is. If it don’t come along good, I’ll make a charm."

Tar & sea salt

Johnny could smell hemp and spices, tar and salt water, the sun drying fish. He liked his wharf. He sat at his own bench, before him the innumerable tools of his trade.

Limes, lemons, & oranges

As Johnny went from house to house talking about unpaid bills of eight shillings, he was thinking of the punch. Not one ship had come into Boston for five months except British ships. Only the British officers had limes, lemons, and oranges these days — they and their friends among the Boston Tories. 

Red coat

Then Johnny saw running down Cambridge road through the bushes on Charlestown Common a scurry of red ants. Had he really seen them or imagined them? But all about him people were exclaiming, ‘Look, there they are!’

Those red ants were British soldiers.

Cracked crucible

Johnny did not see Dove standing on a stool, reaching far back and carefully taking out a cracked crucible. Dusty saw him and giggled. He knew the crack in it was so small it was hard even to see. It might stand the heat of the furnace, but the chances were that it would not. That was why Mr. Lapham had put it so far back. Both he and Dove thought it would just about serve Johnny Tremain right — after the insufferable way he had been bossing everybody — if the crucible gave way and the hot silver did spill all over the top of the furnace. It would certainly make Johnny look like a fool, after all his fussing.

Johnny took the cracked crucible in his trusting hands, put in it silver ingots, set it on top of the furnace.

Old lantern & books

Mr. Lome had a fine library. It was as if Johnny had been starved before and never known it. He read anything — everything. Bound back copies of the Observer, Paradise Lost, Robinson Crusoe [ . . . ] It was a world of which he never had guessed while living with the Laphams, and now he remembered with gratitude how his mother had struggled to teach him so that this world might not be forever closed to him.  

British flag; old spyglass

 Above one tiny shop he saw a sign that attracted him. It was a little man in bright blue coat and red breeches, solemnly gazing at Salt Lane through a spyglass. So this was where the Boston Observer was published. 

LitWitty Shareables



Great Quotes

“We give all we have, lives, property, safety, skill...we fight, we die, for a simple thing. Only that a man can stand up.” 
*
“How old are you Johnny" she asked.
"Sixteen."
"And what's that-a boy or a man?"
He laughed. "A boy in time of peace and a man in time of war.” 
*
And many of the townsfolk of Boston seem more concerned with the profit of their business than the great cause that is swirling around them.
*
After that Johnny began to watch himself. For the first time he learned to think before he spoke.


We're glad you're here!

You're literally on our page about inspiring kids to love great books.  YAY! We're eager to share our passion for LitWitting and the work we've done for over a decade.

We're also eager to keep doing it! :)  So if you found this guide-page inspiring and useful,* please share it with your social world. And if you buy our printables for this book, thank you. We appreciate you helping us keep the lights on at LitWits! 

Happy teaching,
Becky and Jenny
Sisters, best friends, and partners

Terms of Use

The Becky & Jenny version:  Feel free to print pages for teaching use, and make copies of printables for your students. Please don’t use our name, ideas, or materials commercially or share our printables, though we'd love for you to share these free pages with your fellow educators.

The blah legal version: You are granted exclusive use of our products in download or print version as follows: You have the right of reproduction that is limited to your use only in whatever quantity is necessary to meet your needs and those of your student participants. This right is unlimited and extends for as long as you need the materials during which time they cannot be given to or shared with any other person(s) through any means of delivery, materially or digitally via the Internet. As such you have the right to store the product(s) on the hard drive of your computer or as hard copy in your resource file.  Any misuse of these rights is in violation of copyright law.

LitWits® is a registered trademark of LitWits Workshops, LLC.

LitWits teaching ideas and materials for Johnny Tremain  by Esther Forbes
Copyright 2014 by LitWits Workshops, LLC.  All Rights Reserved.

Want ideas for more great books?